Michelle's Front Page

Peanut Butter Pie

February 21st, 2011

Church lady cook books.  Did you all have those growing up?  They were a staple in rural Ohio.  The church ladies would all throw their favorite recipes in and publish a spiral bound cook book to raise funds for something.  Those little cook books were gems.  Sometimes the recipes were downright humorous – find one from the 50′s and count the jello molds.  Sometimes the recipes were fabulous.  Sometimes you wouldn’t know until you tried if whether the recipes was a keeper or not.  This is one of those recipes.  It is one of those that the whole is more than the sum of its parts.  It doesn’t sound like much to read it on paper but it tastes amazing.

I used to make this pie all of the time for picnics and potlucks and gatherings.  And then I lost the cookbook somewhere along the way and I kind of forgot about it.  Fast forward 10 years to a gathering of my friends here in TN.  Some friends were asking Jennie for a recipe for her peanut butter pie.  I heard her mention the ingredients and a light bulb went off in my head.  MY PIE! I asked her to send me the recipe as well.  We started discussing it and found that she had spent some time living in a small town in rural Ohio not far from my hometown.  Her mother had gotten the recipe from a church lady in another town.  We found it funny that our source was possibly the same all these years and miles later.

For some reason, it took me a year after she sent me the recipe to get around to making the pie.  I forgot how yummy it is.  The ingredients are simple.  You’ll see my back story is much longer than the recipe itself.  Make this.  Take it to a picnic.  Everyone will love you.

Church Lady Peanut Butter Pie

1 large box vanilla pudding – cook & serve (Don’t use instant.  If you want to be lazy buy 2 tubs of Kozy Shack prepared pudding.  Also, you can use chocolate and make it more of a reese’s pie.)

1/2 cup peanut butter

1 cup powdered sugar

1 tub of cool whip (8-10 oz)

1 pie shell (you can buy one of the refrigerated ones and bake it or you can use a graham or chocolate crust already prepared…I used chocolate)

Make the pudding according to the directions on the box. Allow it to cool at least to room temperature – it doesn’t have to be chilled but you don’t want it warm enough to melt the peanut butter.

Mix the peanut butter and powdered sugar together with a fork (use it like a pastry cutter).  It will form crumbs.

Put half of the crumb mixture into the bottom of your pie shell.

Put all of the pudding on top of the crumb mixture.  Then put most of the remaining crumb mixture on top of the pudding making sure to get to the edges.  Reserve a couple of tablespoons of the crumb mixture for garnish.

Top with Cool Whip and then the remaining crumb mixture.  Chill.

I took this to Bunco this weekend and everyone seemed to like it a lot.  My husband refused to try it – he has a weird custard issue and said it looked too much like custard.  Whatever.  That just means I don’t have to share when I make it.

Click the button to see more Mouthwatering Monday recipes.

This entry was posted on Monday, February 21st, 2011 at 5:00 am and is filed under food. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Responses are currently closed, but you can trackback from your own site.

24 Responses to “Peanut Butter Pie”

  1. Miz Helen Says:

    Your Peanut Butter pie looks so good. I would like to try your recipe. Thank you for sharing and have a good week!

  2. jane Says:

    Thanks for this. I love the church lady cookbooks…and the Army wives cookbooks…all those special collections of tried and true recipes! We did a family cookbook for a reunion in the 1980′s. The books had 42 pages of desserts and 8 pages of vegetables! Yep, pretty much what I remember about eating at my great-Aunts’ houses as a kid!

  3. Sonia in MO Says:

    I have two of those old church cookbooks from the late 70′s, early 80′s…. and although they are ragged and falling apart, they are still my “go-to” cookbooks when I’m looking for a good comfort dessert :) Although, I have to laugh at a few of the recipes that refer to things like “skinning the hog” or “add one pound of lard”. You can tell we attended a very backwoods, southern church :)

  4. Kim Says:

    Thanks for the recipe. I’ll have to adapt it and try it with sunbutter (1 child has a nut allergy). Sounds easy and yummy.

  5. Trisha Says:

    What a coincidence, I saw a very similar pie on a show on TV y’day and was hoping to find something online. Your pie looks great and I’m sure it tasted divine

  6. Allison @ Alli 'n Son Says:

    My husband would LOVE this.

    I’d love to have you share this recipe with Sweet Tooth Friday! http://alli-n-son.com/2011/02/24/cream-cheese-brownies/

  7. hcg shakes Says:

    Your HCG doctor should have your health in mind, not just the amount
    of money he or she can make from you. The hormone can be ingested into
    our body system either via injections or by using drops.
    I talked to them and learned that the diet works by teaching your
    body’s metabolism to work at a healthier faster rate. Simeons started integrating HCG drops (injections
    back then) into a severe calorie-deficient diet of
    just 500 calories per day, restricted to particular diet.
    h – CG diet drops are all natural hormones that
    the female body produces during the early stages of pregnancy.

    Here is my weblog; hcg shakes

  8. back in the days Says:

    What’s up to all, hoow is the whole thing, I think very
    one is getting more freom this web site, and your iews are fastidious in support of new users.

    Here is my homepage: back in the days

  9. craigslist west palm beach movers Says:

    I couldn’t resist ϲommenting. Perfectly written!

    Feel free to surf to my Ƅlog: craigslist west palm beach movers

  10. Sharron Says:

    Majority of people tend to go for liquid diets taking lemon juices and fruit juices, which is the Master Cleanse Diet.
    This as you might know is contrary to what normally
    happens on a diet. Irrespective of the claims of advertisers
    that the dangers of weight loss injections are limited, it is better to follow a healthy, high protein, and well balanced
    eating plan.

    Here is my web-site; hcg weight loss hormone (Sharron)

  11. french connection bandage dress size chart Says:

    Yes, fashion trends are referential and recurring, but
    at the same time new ones pop up, allowing us to visually reflect the world around us.

    You can correct and adjust the ready made design pattern at your will.

    By searching on the net, one can find hundreds of fashion industry portals where all
    kinds of information related to European fashion are available in detail.

    Also visit my website; french connection bandage dress size chart

  12. discount miami movers Says:

    Finding the right house for your family means finding the best nest will help
    you to take care of your kids better. Some complete assistance moving companies would raise
    the price on the day of the shift and cause scuffles.
    Getting the services of Long Distance Moving Company make your moving easy and very much less taxing.

    Feel free to surf to my site; discount miami movers

  13. clarisonic pro on sale Says:

    You would be right depending on your understanding of certain points.
    Having a well hydrated body is a sure way of having your energy levels high at all times.
    But who has the time to go through all that information.

    Feel free to visit my site: clarisonic pro on sale

  14. Top Skin Products Says:

    So, if you are really looking forward to get rid of all your skin problems
    in a natural way, get all solutions on. Oils such as jojoba, linseed, evening primrose, and shea butter moisturizes.
    It must be protected well if the body is
    to be kept safe and healthy without any serious problems.

    Also visit my weblog … Top Skin Products

  15. hcg drops for healthy weight loss yahoo Says:

    If done correctly, you can lose 2 to 4 pounds in just a single day.
    All such things are done so that the consumer can get a flawless and
    reliable product. Just because you really feel you have to lose
    weight fast and easily doesn’t mean you should bypass your physician and click the “Buy” button without really being aware what you’re getting into.

    My blog: hcg drops for healthy weight loss yahoo

  16. moving services columbus ohio Says:

    The cost of the moving mainly depends on the large number of variables; some of the variables include quantity of things being moved, differences in prices between companies, distance to be
    covered, time duration that would be taken for the move, number of people
    involved in packing, loading and unloading. As I am communicating
    services, Practical goal referring to the switching your property from stage A to suggest M.
    Most of the Denver moving companies make use of quality packing boxes.

    Also visit my page; moving services columbus ohio

  17. fort lauderdale Cpa supplies Says:

    Then visit this endorsed web-page and discover how Accountant
    Burnsville can benefit you. Here are 4 things bookkeeping and accounting
    services do for their customers:. Accounting software
    should contain common features such as accounts receivable,
    accounts payable, banking, payroll, inventory control, time costing, job costing, fixed assets and conversions and updates and more.

    Also visit my website :: fort lauderdale Cpa supplies

  18. plastic surgery before and after Says:

    Advanced Plastic Surgery is here to celebrate
    beauty with its state of the art facilities and innovative services such as
    dermabrasion, BOTOX Cosmetic, body surgeries, and the latest Vi – Peel.
    In recent years the term “mommy-makeover” has become more common. There is no question that how you
    look has an impact in the workplace.

    Also visit my site: plastic surgery before and after

  19. eye clinic brooklyn Says:

    It contains antioxidants and brightens dark circles under the
    eyes. They have much cooperative nature and always work with honestly.
    You need to stop wearing contact lenses even before having a consultation with your optometrist because contact lenses change the shape
    of your cornea.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog … eye clinic brooklyn

  20. backflow prevention pompano beach florida Says:

    In addition to it we should also try to provide superior quality plumbing services for
    the better functioning of our plumbing appliances and fixtures.
    No, we can’t bear it so to avoid it we use some chemicals
    by which we get rid of the smell. False or deceptive advertisement is an advertising misrepresenting the nature, characteristics, qualities,
    or geographic origin of goods, services, or commercial
    activities. You will have no more electrical elements
    to replace or having to buy a new water heater, when built
    up sediment eventually shortens its life. The appearance of more than one Tom
    Clancy title means it has done well in providing Nintendo fans with hardcore Wii games.
    You need to consider a few things before calling someone out, as countless times
    in the past people regret using a company, as
    they did a bad job or were rude and obnoxious and overcharged.
    Before you choose to ask for a home rebuilding loan, first be very sure of the improvements or changes you need
    to make in a home. The non-automatic pumps (BN53, N59, N137, N139) give even more flexibility since they
    allow for adding an external variable level tether or vertical float to be attached to the discharge pipe at the desired height of its user.
    Follow the below listed steps in case of plumbing emergencies, before seeking further assistance:.
    If you are preparing to take an even additional step, you may also check out
    an expert plumber and ask to join him as an internee.

    my web site :: backflow prevention pompano beach florida

  21. boca raton camps kids Says:

    Some of our favorite camp foods can actually be a source for a good thematic
    unit. “The more guests feel involved with your wedding, the more likely they will have a great time. Make a list of the items in your kitchen in categories and determine whether you really need them to be present in that place. While some soccer camps for kids are reasonably priced there are those that can be very expensive, especially in certain areas. If leaves are not an option, you can easily substitute any object for this lesson. For children interested in the environment, or even for kids who do not have the opportunity to spend time in nature, children’s eco camp is a unique experience. My experiences for 6 years as a camper and more than a dozen years as a counselor, waterfront director and eventually program director have taught me that there are plenty of things that kids hate about summer camp. We started crawling through mud, under barbed wire, we climbed walls and we coordinated a team response to simulated enemy attacks. You can even rent your own beach cabana for added privacy. Eggs your way but will be dumped in at end so don,t pre-cook.

    My web blog boca raton camps kids

  22. boca raton internet marketing resources Says:

    You can market your biz op after you build a relationship with them.
    It really doesn’t make a difference if you’re an international hotel
    chain or a small brand, social media can certainly benefit you immensely.

    Watch for requests to come in, and accept as appropriate.
    This will help increase their trust in you, which will make them do business with you rather than your competition. Follow these four strategies and you’ll be on your way to accomplishing your goals.
    Marketing consultant is capable of applying appropriate strategies for websites to create the needed traffic and increase sales.
    Once a marketing campaign has been implemented, businesses can easily keep track of the metrics that
    will then provide them with up-to-date and in-depth analysis of the different campaigns.
    The web is seriously serious business, but there’s nothing to fear but fear itself.
    Tweeting on Twitter linking visual messages can be your best
    use of social media. A perfect solution is that to find out the cheap
    Facebook likes, which will be less in cost and superior
    in result.

    Take a look at my web blog :: boca raton internet marketing resources

  23. boca raton resmed cpa supplies Says:

    Professional responsibility principles should be incorporated into every area of office operations and procedures.
    It provides comprehensive solutions to every accounting problem related to your business.
    The online offering will cost you $99 to setup
    up with monthly fees.

    Also visit my blog: boca raton resmed cpa supplies

  24. certain items together Says:

    visit the following website page

    Michelle Smiles

beats by dr dre monster beats cuffie beats fitflop italia scarpe fitflop fitflop online ray ban wayfarer occhiali ray ban occhiali da sole ray ban scarpe louboutin louboutin scarpe louboutin prezzi peuterey peuterey outlet